top of page

The Lindsay Clancy Case

Jo42Blog
Aug 31
7 min read

Today is the day we may very well get a verdict in the case that has gone transatlantic, perhaps even global for all I know.


For those who haven’t heard about it, Lindsay Clancy is a former labour and delivery nurse who strangled her three children to death: Cora, age 5; Dawson, age 3 and Callan, 8 months. She is being tried for the 2023 killing and her defence team are not disputing that the children died by her hands.


Lindsay’s defence team have spent 5 weeks arguing that she did this under the influence of a post-partum psychotic break, and that she was repeatedly failed in her attempts to seek help with her post-partum depression, making her a victim.


This case has become a focus of campaigners for the rights of women and mothers, and while I consider myself to be a supporter of women’s rights, this was the first thing that left a bad taste in my mouth when the case finally came to my attention here in the UK. Because in crying Lindsay Clancy’s name from the rooftops, no-one seems to be crying for Cora, Dawson or Callan.


Callan, unlike his older siblings, did not die at the home where the incident took place. Instead, he lived for 3 days on ventilation and life support. It was established that his brain injuries were significant, with no hope of recovery, so life support was withdrawn from the infant who subsequently died.


Lindsay claims she heard a persistent, male voice telling her she must kill her children NOW, before succumbing to the suicidal urges she had been battling for months. The voice said this was her last chance and the only way to keep herself and her children safe. This phenomenon is called a command hallucination. One of the main arguments of the prosecution is that Lindsay did not report hearing voices at any point except for the approximately 20-minute window it took to strangle each of her three children in turn. An expert testified that this would be unusual and the carrying out of the act does not usually lead to the cessation the voices. The defence argue Lindsay did not report the voices because she was afraid they would take her children away. She had reported thoughts of harming her children though.


She would not be the first person who killed their child/children believing they were protecting them. This type of action is named altruistic filicide. I would argue that a mother carrying out this act does so in a gentle manner, often drugging the children so they won’t feel anything. She does not coax or carry them, one by one, down to the basement then tie an exercise band around their necks, tightening it until their oxygen is sufficiently restricted to cause death, while they are fully aware of what is happening to them. I struggle to believe that in the repeated journeys up and down to the basement, and in the three separate instances of carrying out the act, which I imagine must have sparked visible pain and terror in each child, Lindsay would not have come to her senses. She had continued to care for her children. Testimony was heard that even in the months she struggled with PPD, she was a wonderful mother. She had been building a snowman and doing arts and crafts with the children the very day the children died.


I won’t go into all the details of my own mental health journey, but I was first diagnosed almost 30 years ago and have made two attempts to end my life. I was recorded as having post-natal depression after the birth of my daughter, but cannot remember why this was diagnosed, given that I was already suffering from depression. What I do know is that even at my lowest points, when others had to step in and help with the practical care of the children whilst putting food in my hands, so that I was actually eating, not once did I think of harming my children. I had occasion to call a mental health helpline after a trip to the supermarket, where I had lost my temper with my son and shook him by the arms while he sat in the shopping trolley. The operator at the other end said I was overeacting to something that hundreds of mothers do every day, that it was perfectly normal and not a result of my depression. I disagree – we should never lay hands on anyone for anything other than positive purposes, especially not our children. What I have not experienced is psychosis, although family members have and their children were never physically harmed as a result.


It is statistically proven that a father is more likely to use an external tool, like the exercise bands, in the commission of altruistic filicide. This brings me to the greater social impact of this case besides Lindsay becoming a poster girl for women’s rights. True crime fans and online sleuths have grasped onto this case. They mainly believe, based on genuine inconsistencies, that Lindsay did not in fact commit this act at all. They are convinced that her husband and the father of Cora, Dawson and Callan, was the perpetrator, and that he has convinced Lindsay she did it.


Here’s what I think: Patrick Clancy was very likely having an affair. He remarried in April 2026, having been with his new wife, publicly at least, from around 13 months after the children were killed. And yes, there are issues with timelines and outfits and other things that make him look suspicious, but some of those I believe I can explain.


I think the prosecution knows he was having an affair. I think they accepted his responses of “I don’t know” and “I don’t remember” because the answer is that he was communicating with his mistress. If it comes out that he was having an affair, it messes with the prosecution’s case massively. Patrick Clancy has been compared, by those who feel he is guilty, to another American family annihilator who killed his children and pregnant wife to start a new life with his mistress. Reasonable doubt is all it takes for the Commonwealth to lose this case.


Furthermore, I suspect the defence may also know he was having an affair. For them, the case would become overly complicated if this fact was included, confusing the defence of diminished responsibility. It would also have a harmful effect on their client. On balance, it is probably in their best interest to keep it out of the courtroom. Not to protect Patrick Clancy – adulterers do not deserve to be protected – but to protect the case, keep the important facts front and centre, and to protect their client.


Here’s what I think about Lindsay Clancy’s culpability: I think she planned the act and killed the children to punish her husband because she knew or at least suspected his affair. I buy the prosecution’s argument that she didn’t really mean to kill herself, but I’m not fully convinced. I think killing herself was also part of the punishment, but there is some likelihood that she hoped she could walk away from an attempted suicide that would make her defence all the more believable.


I believe Patrick Clancy was genuinely horrified to find the bodies of Cora and Dawson, and the unresponsive Callan still with the exercise band tied round his neck. I think he is a bit of a “cold fish,” potentially on the spectrum, which accounts in part for his demeanour on the stand. I think he is generally out of touch and unfocussed in his personal life – unaware of prearranged check ups for the kids, needing the names of medication texted to him - but completely the opposite in his professional life; something that fits with a neurodiverse profile but could also explain why he was unclear about some details when questioned and why he didn’t hang up on the 911 call when he went to the basement. It also fits with the portrait that has been painted in court of Lindsay being in full control of their home life and everything involving the children.


I am willing to accept that Lindsay Clancy was indeed suffering from a mental disease or defect that led to the death of her children if that is the finding of the jury. I have not heard all the evidence, and I am only working on my intuition and personal experiences with mental health struggles.

What I am certain of though, and what really leaves a bad taste in my mouth, is that if Lindsay Clancy were a man, he would not have this level of public support. Not only that, but if Lindsay Clancy was black, poor, an addict, she would not have the public support OR legal support that this wealthy, Christian, white woman is receiving. But at least in those instances, the outcry would be over the deaths of Cora, Dawson and Callan, although I doubt it would be as loud in most of the hypothetical cases I’ve suggested. Even if there were no partner or other parent to blame; even if the psychosis was far more strongly evidenced; a man or a black, poor or addict female would not have a fraction of the people in their corner that Lindsay Clancy has.


That is not okay. That is not equality. And nothing about this honours the lives and loss of Cora, Dawson and Callan.

RIP Cora, Dawson and Callan
RIP Cora, Dawson and Callan

TL;DR: In my opinion, Lindsay Clancy is guilty, her motive likely knowing or suspecting infidelity. The bigger issue here is the lack of public outcry on behalf of the children, and the fact that much of Lindsay’s support is a privilege of being a rich, white, Christian woman. There would be nothing like this level of support for a man or a poor, black or addict female even if the evidence for them was stronger than it is for Lindsay Clancy.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Let’s Talk About Macklemore…

And if it feels like everyone already is, well so they should be. For once, it is not a fashion fail or a relationship indiscretion that has a music star hitting the headlines. In a world where right

 
 
 
Unrequited Love and the Confusion of Mixed Signals.

This post…it doesn’t come with the answers. It is the first post where I can offer no suggestions or explanations, no words of wisdom or experience that has brought clarity to the matter. I have been

 
 
 

Comments


© JFWriter

Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page